Nature of Ethics  

Man is a social animal.  For most of us, we are raised in social groupings and live our entire lives in social settings.  Ostracism or exile is one of the harshest punishments imaginable, whether it is a formal banishment or simply that our social clique no longer considers us "part of the old gang".  Most of us like to think that we are civilized.  But that word, "civilized", simply means to live in a city that is to say, among many other fellow human beings.    Which raises a point that has been addressed by philosophers from time immemorial: "How are we supposed to treat those we live with, and how should we expect them to treat us?"  


This chapter will examine the nature of ethics, consider the parties to whom the agent owes an ethical duty, and identify a few ethical yardsticks against which our actions can be measured.


What are Ethics?


In practical terms, ethics is a system or code of principles that directs our actions towards others. Before trying to apply the precepts of any ethical system to the complex and important job of the financial services agent, it seems sensible to look somewhat deeper into this system that we know as ethics and understand the principles on which it is based.  Not surprisingly, the foundational ethical standards that apply to the financial services agent in his or her interaction with customers or represented companies are the same that serve as the building blocks of the earth's great religions: the Golden Rule.  The Golden Rule maintains that each of us should treat others as he or she would wish to be treated.


Judaism: Thou shalt regard thy neighbor as thyself.

Buddhism: Hurt not others with that which pains yourself.

Islam: No one of you is a believer until he loves for his brother what he loves for himself.

Hinduism: Good people proceed while considering that what is best for others is best for themselves.

Christianity: Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.

Confucianism: What you do not want done to yourself, do not do to others.


Modeling our actions towards others -- our customers and companies, in this case on what we want for ourselves is not only eminently fair, it is also essential for a civilized society.  Consider the alternative to this precept of fairness.  


In a society in which you were the only member, there would be little need for ethics.  You would be the beneficiary of all of its goods as well as the bearer of all of its burdens; there would be nobody eager to share your goods, nor would you be expected to shoulder anyone else's burdens.  It is the fact we don't exist alone -- and that goods exist in limited supply while burdens seem unlimited which makes a system of ethics essential.  Limited goods must be distributed and burdens shared, and that means that we will disagree.  The important question is how that disagreement should be resolved.


There are two fundamental means of dispute resolution: through the use of force and through the use of reason.  Any other way is only a subset of these two.


If you use force to resolve a dispute by brandishing a weapon or making a threat, for example you may be able to carry the day, but at what cost?  Your use of force has probably destroyed any possibility of an enduring relationship.  The next time a similar dispute arises, your adversary may use a larger weapon, and the result may be different.  


In addition to possible adverse outcomes that may arise from the use of force, we also risk the loss of positive relationships. Most of us value our relationships with others -- we are, after all, social animals so force isn't the answer.


However, if you choose to use reason instead of force to resolve disputes and, thereby, promote relationship, what principle is likely to be the most palatable to everyone?  The answer, of course, is the Golden Rule: specifically, I will treat you in the way that I want you to treat me, and I want you to treat me as you would treat yourself.


Assuming that you have a healthy self-image and, therefore, treat yourself well, the Golden Rule becomes the most rational method of dispute resolution.  Taken to the next step, it is the very core of fairness and the fundamental element of professionalism.  It is this fairness that is the basic character of any viable system of ethics.



Chapter 1 Contents



Text Box:   2009 Wall Street Instructors, Inc. No part of this material may be reproduced without the written permission of the publisher.