Annuity Suitability5

One of the key responsibilities for any financial advisor is to determine whether a recommendation is suitable for a particular client.  In some ways, suitability is a nebulous concept to describe.   Justice Potter Stewart famously wrote in a Supreme Court decision that pornography is difficult to describe but "I know it when I see it". The same could be said for suitability there are no hard and fast guidelines as to what is or is not suitable, but unsuitable recommendations are relatively easy to spot.      


Suitability should always be viewed from each client's unique perspective.  Advisors should not start with a product to be sold and ask themselves "which clients would this be suitable for?"  Rather, the advisor should carefully analyze the client's needs and circumstances to determine which investments may be suitable for that particular client.  


All regulatory authorities place suitability at the center of their consumer protection regulations.    While each organization may define suitability differently, all agree that suitability is the "appropriateness of recommended transactions when considering the risks associated with a transaction relative to a customer’s financial situation, financial needs and investment objectives".  (This is the language used in Florida state law.  The SEC has a similar standard: “This duty generally requires an investment adviser to determine that the investment advice it gives to a client is suitable for the client, taking into consideration the client’s financial situation, investment experience and investment objectives.”)


An ethical corollary to the suitability requirements is that of fiduciary.  Clients trust their advisors to provide objective investment recommendations.  As such, advisors have a fiduciary responsibility to place the client's interest above their own self-interest.


In the previous chapter we reviewed various types of clients and their general investment objectives (accumulation, conservation, distribution and transfer).  We also explored a number of other investment factors clients may have, such as:


¨ the need for liquidity,

¨ the client’s tax situation,

¨ investment horizon,

¨ risk aversion,

¨ sophistication;

¨ the need for creditor protection, and

¨ estate planning considerations. 


We also reviewed when various types of annuities might be appropriate in light of those factors.  In this chapter we'll look at how a client's financial situation may affect their investment choices, and the recommendation of annuities in light of other investments in the client's portfolio and other investment alternatives in the marketplace.




Client's Financial Situation and Needs


Before making any recommendations, advisors should carefully review a prospect's current and projected financial situation.   This starts with basic personal information such as


¨ the client's age,

¨ marital status,

¨ number of dependents and their ages.  


As we learned in Chapter 4, an investor's age is a key factor in a changing spectrum of investment objectives over the investor's lifetime.  Given the increasing lifespan of Americans, it's important to note that dependents are not limited to the client's children -- many clients now find themselves supporting their parents in later life.  Likewise, today’s high divorce and remarriage rates create blended families that now present a wider set of dependents (e.g., stepchildren living in the investor's household or child support payments for natural children living with an ex-spouse) than the traditional, nuclear family.



Assets & Liabilities


Once basic information is obtained the advisor should review the investor's financial circumstances, typically in the form of a personal balance sheet and income statement.  The basic balance sheet equation assets minus liabilities equals net worth -- is a convenient place to start the review.  While it is helpful to be as accurate as possible, approximate values for assets and liabilities are usually adequate for this task. 


In addition to the assets’ values, advisors should be aware of the types of assets and liabilities the investors has.  In the case of assets, it is important to distinguish between liquid assets and illiquid assets.   Some investors are, as old farmers used to say, "land rich and cash poor"; others may hold nothing but liquid assets.  The investor's liquidity position is an important factor in this decision to invest in deferred annuities, which typically impose steep surrender charges on withdrawals in the early years of the contract.    All investors should have some liquidity cushion to meet everyday expenses and unforeseen emergencies.  


Regarding the investor's longer-term assets and investments, the advisor should inquire as to the nature of those holdings. Some of these assets may be viewed as "pure investments" -- holdings that can be redeployed without other personal considerations, such as a portfolio of stocks and bonds.  Other investments such as the investor's primary residence and vacation homes, ownership in a business, real estate used by the investor's business or inherited property are much more entwined in the investor's lifestyle and have may have significant personal, as well as financial, considerations.  Also, some investments, such as retirement plan holdings limit access to those funds during the employees working years, and the tax code imposes additional penalties for withdrawals at younger ages.  Advisors should be aware of these constraints.


Advisors should also examine the investor's liabilities.  Like assets, liabilities can be classified as short-term and long-term.  The short-term liabilities should be viewed in tandem with liquid assets.    Debts that need to be repaid in the near future will typically drain the investor's liquid assets.  So what may appear to be an adequate liquidity position today may, in the not-too-distant future, become quickly inadequate.  As for long-term liabilities, the advisor should distinguish between debts that are self-amortizing and those that will require a lump sum repayment.  Mortgages and car loans amortize over time and those debts are retired a little at a time through routine periodic payments.  On the other hand, a mortgage with a balloon payment or an agreement to purchase a retiring partner's business interest create a need to raise cash at "maturity" -- which in turn may affect the investment objectives, or at the least shorten an investor's investment horizon.  Another question financial advisors should ask is whether the investor is prone to lawsuits or legal judgments.  These may create new liabilities in the future.  As we discussed in Chapter 4, annuities (and other insurance products) offer better protection against creditor claims than other investment options.  


Before moving on to income and expenses, a quick note about life insurance.  The cash value within a whole life insurance policy (or universal or variable policy) should certainly be viewed as a liquid asset on the investor's balance sheet.   But the face value of the policy should not be treated as a long-term asset on the balance sheet.   The policy's death benefits can provide protection for beneficiaries in the event of the investor's death but will not provide any value during the investor's lifetime.  Exploration of proper life insurance planning is beyond the scope of this course, but advisors should consider the investor's insurance needs (income protection for survivors, debt repayment, etc.)  Annuities only provide for return of principal (and accumulated earnings), and therefore should not be viewed as a suitable substitute for true life insurance coverage, which can create a larger pool of capital in the event of the investor's death.  



Income & Expenses


Before making suitable recommendations, advisors must inquire into their clients' income and expenses. An adequate income is the key to maintaining one's lifestyle (i.e., expenses).    Income typically comes from one of two sources: earnings and investments.   In the investor's younger years, presumably with few investments, most income will be earned income.  As the investor accumulates wealth, some of his or her investments may generate "unearned" income dividends from stocks and mutual funds, interest from bank accounts and bonds, rent from real estate holdings, etc. In later years, after retirement for example, the investor will rely primarily on "unearned" income from private investments, plus pensions and Social Security.     An advisor should compare his or her clients' income with their expenses, to ascertain the need to augment current income from their investments.


All of this should be done with an eye on current -- and projected -- income and expenses.    Over time, sources of income will vary -- younger workers typically rely on earned income; older clients on investment income.  Advisors should also note that some occupations are relatively stable sources of income, while other positions may be subject to wide variations.  Consider, for example, two employees of the same company earning $75,000 this year one is a salaried office worker and the other is a salesman working on commissions.  While the current income level appears to be the same, the commissioned sales position is a less certain source of future earnings.  A financial advisor should be aware of such differences, and adjust his or her recommendations accordingly.   Similarly, some career paths are shorter than others. Professional athletes have relatively few years to make their "nest egg", as do other physically demanding occupations while less strenuous jobs allow clients to continue to work into their later years.  Disability income policies can be helpful in assuring income in the future.   Obviously, the client's projected retirement date also has an impact on projected future income.     Projected expenses will vary over time, too.  Clients may face college tuition, medical expenses, or long-term care costs for themselves or dependents.  To the extent that these can be foreseen, financial advisors should take these into consideration when making recommendations.  Some of these costs can be addressed proactively: pre-paid college plans, long-term care insurance, and medical expense policies, and so on.     


If income falls short of expenses, investments can be redeployed from those seeking capital appreciation to those generating more income.  The purchase of an immediate annuity can serve that function as can annuitization of a deferred annuity.  




One expense bears special consideration: taxes.  Annuities offer investors a bundle of features, but one of the most important is the tax-deferred growth they provide. That tax advantage is of more value to investors in relatively high tax brackets.  An advisor should carefully review a client’s tax status including the client’s filing status (single, married, etc.), the client’s current and projected marginal tax rate (“tax bracket”), as well as the sources of the client’s taxable income.  Different sources of income have different tax treatment:  ordinary income from paychecks, capital gains from security trades, passive income from tax shelters, and business income passed through to the client from S corporations.    In order to make suitable recommendations, an advisor must have a clear understanding of how an annuity fits into the client’s overall tax situation.



Financial goals


While the need to save and invest for a comfortable retirement is nearly universal for individual investors, that is not the only goal most investors have.  Young families may want to save for their children's college education or a down payment on a new home.  Budding entrepreneurs may want to start a business.  Established businesspersons may wish to buy-out a retiring partner's interest.  All of these require accumulation of capital.  The thing that distinguishes them is the length of each investor's investment horizon.  Recommending an illiquid investment to a client with a short-term investment horizon is unsuitable, even if the investment eventually turns out to be highly profitable.  Generally speaking, recommendations of conservative and liquid investments are more suitable for clients with shorter investment horizons.  Clients with long-term horizons can more easily handle illiquid and more speculative investments.



< prev page     1  2  3   next page >




Chapter 5 Contents


Client’s Financial Situation

           assets & liabilities

           income & expenses

           financial goals

Existing Investments

           existing annuities

           annuities vs. other investments: fixed, variable, indexed


Course Contents                 Contact an Instructor

             print version (pdf)